You are using an older browser version. Please use a supported version for the best MSN experience.

India's Goods-and-Services Tax Is a Work in Progress: Editorial

Bloomberg logoBloomberg 20-07-2017 The Editors

(Bloomberg View) -- A country rarely praised for its efficient bureaucracy, India has managed its biggest administrative reform in years pretty well. Its new goods-and-services tax, replacing 40 other taxes and levies, came into force earlier this month without undue disruption. This policy deserves to be a great success -- but to make the most of it, the government still has work to do.

How does GST affect your budget?

Prime Minister Narendra Modi's previous big idea -- declaring 86 percent of India's banknotes void overnight -- took the public by surprise and caused the economy to seize up. Employers couldn't pay wages and workers couldn't buy even basic staples. The full cost of the disruption is still being calculated.

Complete coverage on Goods and Services Tax (GST)

After that, fears about the GST roll-out ran high. Too high, as it turned out. It helped that the plan was not a shock: Successive administrations had debated the idea for years. The government also adjusted the rules to appease various constituencies, and gave businesses a two-month cushion to comply.

Partly for that reason, though, the project is far from finished. In excluding certain goods from the scheme, the central government has given state governments discretion to raise taxes on them at any time. Some states have already tried to impose taxes and fees on products already taxed under GST, including automobiles and movie tickets. The infamous customs posts where truck drivers had to halt and fill out paperwork before crossing a state line have begun to come down -- but local officials can still clog the roads by demanding inspections or fees.

The new tax is also giving rise to new kinds of regulation. An "anti-profiteering" clause threatens companies with fines or closure if they don't pass GST-related savings on to consumers. 


(Video provided by India Today)

India's Aspirations

All this undermines the whole purpose of GST -- to simplify a complex and fractured system. The design of the tax itself makes things worse. Long negotiations have produced a convoluted structure. Goods are divided into four or five different tax brackets (some are subject to additional "sin" charges as well), in ways that don't always make sense. Hotel rooms are charged at different rates depending on how expensive they are; food at restaurants with air-conditioning is taxed at a higher rate than at those without. This will encourage companies to game the system and agitate for shifting their goods into lower brackets.  

To head this off, the government should keep working on simplifying the system -- narrowing exemptions as far as possible and reducing the number of tax brackets to one or two. Officials say that this is their eventual goal, but too much delay could be fatal. The longer tax preferences are in place, the harder they'll be to dislodge. Companies will fight to keep their products in lower brackets, and tax officials will resist efforts to curtail their powers.

The roll-out went well. But if the government wants this reform to be a lasting success, it can't afford to relax.   

--Editors: Nisid Hajari, Clive Crook

To contact the senior editor responsible for Bloomberg View’s editorials: David Shipley at

For more columns from Bloomberg View, visit

©2017 Bloomberg L.P.

image beaconimage beaconimage beacon