You are using an older browser version. Please use a supported version for the best MSN experience.

Why Minnesota’s Boundary Waters Are on the Ballot This Year

Men's Journal logoMen's Journal 10/30/2020 Men's Journal editors
a large body of water surrounded by trees: 100 adventures public lands © Travis J. Camp / Shutterstock 100 adventures public lands

How we protect and intend to use the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness is on the ballot this election, as is the Tongass National Forest in Alaska, the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, Idaho’s South Fork Salmon River, Bristol Bay, Bears Ears National Monument, and countless other public lands.

Ely, Minnesota was once a thriving iron mining capital, whose modern identity is now synonymous with the largest wilderness area east of the Rocky Mountains: the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness. That wilderness (the most heavily used in the U.S., attracting a quarter million visitors a year) now finds itself at odds with a foreign-owned copper/nickel mine—one that had been suspended, pending further research under the previous administration, and is now being fast-tracked by the current one.

a small boat in a body of water: northern Minnesota's boundary waters © Provided by Men's Journal northern Minnesota's boundary waters

The massive underground project, underway just a couple miles (or a long portage) away from the wilderness boundary, promises to bring jobs back to the economically depressed Iron Range, but simultaneously threatens to permanently taint this 1.1 million-acre network of intact boreal forest and pristine lakes, bogs, and streams for generations to come. The risk of toxic sulfide runoff from the tailings and waste rock entering the intricate and interconnected hydrology of this region is seen by many experts as inevitable; the heavy metal- and acid-laced consequences remaining in the water and land for centuries.

a dog that is standing in the snow: Dog Sled Cochrane 9 © Provided by Men's Journal Dog Sled Cochrane 9

Dispatches: Running Sled Dogs Across the Boundary Waters

Read article a sunset over a body of water: canoeing the boundary waters © Provided by Men's Journal canoeing the boundary waters

These two competing histories, resource extraction and wilderness conservation, have overlapped since the early 1900s and have reached a new level of tension. On one hand, this region sorely needs a boost in its economy to sustain communities like Ely, which one could argue will contribute to furthering its wilderness adventure industry. But on the other hand, a future Superfund site, where the Boundary Waters once was, is hardly the job generator anyone wants. The long-term environmental damage risks dashing all manner of future economic hopes against the copper-rich rocks below. And so, the fate of Ely and the Boundary Waters doesn’t need to be at the whim of a Chilean-Canadian multinational mining conglomerate; choice lies in the hands of American voters at local, state, and national levels.

a group of people walking on a road: RootRiver5[8][1] © Provided by Men's Journal RootRiver5[8][1]

The Paddlers who Portage a Minnesota Marathon

The Longest Rod: Boundary Waters punishment gluttons take on unique challenge of the 26.2-mile (8,39...

Read article a group of clouds in the sky: Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness © Provided by Men's Journal Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness

These tough choices between economic gains and environmental stability are playing out in small rural towns all across the country.

And accordingly, conservation of our ever-shrinking wild and scenic lands tends to create polarizing stances: locals against visitors; industry against ecosystems; environmentalists against capitalists. But many Americans believe in the value of public lands and wild spaces. Most support sustaining these places for future generations. After all, the miners from the Iron Range hunt, fish, and paddle the same waterways as the lawyers from Minneapolis. Of course, we humans will continue to need to extract natural resources from the earth. How we balance these two needs is what’s actually up for debate (and on the ballot), which unfortunately, through blind partisanship, often muddies the waters of what’s actually at stake: rare public, wild lands.

We need to work together, listen to all stakeholders, and seek to truly understand the real consequences of our decisions that will affect our fellow citizens and our collectively owned landscapes for generations. Protecting wilderness for all people to use is one of the great American traditions. And while we may disagree on how to preserve, use, and live among these singular and limited wild places, let’s not pretend for a moment that the importance of these wild public places is up for debate.

Luckily, we have another great American tradition coming up on Tuesday: a free election where your VOTE counts!

Read up more on Twin Metals plan and its resulting environmental impact.

100 adventures public lands © Provided by Men's Journal 100 adventures public lands

100 Best Adventures in America on Public Lands

Read article

More From Men's Journal

image beaconimage beaconimage beacon