You are using an older browser version. Please use a supported version for the best MSN experience.

Republican-drawn congressional map struck down by Ohio state supreme court

MarketWatch logo MarketWatch 1/14/2022 Associated Press
© jeff dean/Agence France-Presse/Getty Images

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — The Ohio Supreme Court rejected a new map of state congressional districts Friday as gerrymandered, sending the blueprint back for another try.

Video: Gerrymandered Ohio map deemed unconstitutional (MSNBC)


In the 4-3 decision, justices returned the map to the powerful Ohio Redistricting Commission, or its map-drawing counterparts in the legislature, and said they must assure the next plan actually complies with the Ohio constitution.

The commission was already reconstituting to redraw legislative maps rejected Wednesday.

See: Ohio Supreme Court tosses out Republican-drawn statehouse maps

Writing for the majority, Justice Michael Donnelly, one of the court’s three Democrats, wrote, “[T]he evidence in these cases makes clear beyond all doubt that the General Assembly did not heed the clarion call sent by Ohio voters to stop political gerrymandering.”

The court’s three Democrats were joined by Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor, a moderate Republican set to depart the court due to age limits at the end of the year. She is 70.

The decision affects separate lawsuits brought by voting-rights and Democratic groups, which argued it was indisputable that the map unconstitutionally “‘unduly’ favors the Republican Party.” The two suits were brought by the National Democratic Redistricting Commission’s legal arm, as well as the Ohio offices of the League of Women Voters and the A. Philip Randolph Institute.

The groups said either 12 or 13 of the map’s 15 districts favor Republicans, despite the GOP garnering only about 54% of votes in statewide races over the past decade.

In the past two presidential elections, Donald Trump, a Republican, carried the state over Democrats Joe Biden and Hillary Clinton by margins of 53.3% to 45.2% and 51.7% to 43.6%, respectively. Democratic former president Barack Obama won Ohio in 2008 and 2012.

Ohio voters approved a constitutional amendment in 2018 that set up a new system to avoid gerrymandering.

The court’s three other Republicans — including Justice Pat DeWine, son of Republican Gov. Mike DeWine, a named plaintiff in the cases — dissented. They said it was unclear how it should be determined that a map “unduly favors” one party over another.

“When the majority says that the plan unduly favors the Republican Party, what it means is that the plan unduly favors the Republican Party as compared to the results that would be obtained if we followed a system of proportional representation,” the dissent said.

Republicans had defended the map as “highly competitive.”

Ohio and other states were required to redraw their congressional maps to reflect results of the 2020 census, under which Ohio lost one of its current 16 districts due to lagging population.

MarketWatch contributed.


More from Marketwatch

image beaconimage beaconimage beacon