Why Tesla's decision to accept bitcoin as payment is unlikely to be followed by other companies

© NurPhoto/Getty Images NurPhoto/Getty Images

• The volatility in the market price of bitcoin could present a challenge for e-commerce merchants.
• That would stop them from following Tesla's decision to adopt bitcoin as payment for products.
• Some companies may make the leap, but most are fiscally conservative, Webull's CEO said.
• Sign up here for our daily newsletter, 10 Things Before the Opening Bell.

Elon Musk announced this week Tesla has begun to accept bitcoin as payment for all models of its cars in the US.

From a transactional perspective, the billionaire's crypto-related announcements have been game-changing for bitcoin. That is quite evident from statistics showing crypto-related keyword searches on Google such as "invest in bitcoin" and "how to trade crypto" have seen more than a 1,015% jump in search volume since January alone, according to data from Semrush.

But some crypto experts say this is an unstable choice for Tesla and could deter other companies from following. Here are four main factors that make the cryptocurrency an impractical and costly method of payment for corporates.

Volatility

With a market cap that now exceeds $1 trillion, bitcoin has quickly acquired a status of being a digital global store of value and reserve asset. But hourly price fluctuations make it extremely volatile, impractical, and a costly payment method for corporates, according to Megan Kaspar, co-founder of crypto investment firm Magnetic. That makes the currency a "poor medium of exchange" and a risky method of payment. Sudden price fluctuations could negatively impact a customer's ability to pay in bitcoin, she said.

A fintech expert said Musk's decision is more like an experiment that will measure potential revenue and client type for his products. This step should be assumed to be one of the automaker's tests for its payment mechanisms, he said.

Video: New phishing scam targets U.S. taxpayers for personal information and tax refunds (CNBC)

New phishing scam targets U.S. taxpayers for personal information and tax refunds

CNBC See more videos

SHARE

SHARE

TWEET

SHARE

EMAIL

What to watch next

• 

  7 muscle cars that are reasonably priced

  
  GOBankingRates
• 

  Tesla Model 3: The Complete Guide

  
  Car and Driver
• 

  First driving impressions of the McLaren 600LT Spider

  
  Roadshow
• 

  2020 Lincoln Corsair road test

  
  Consumer Reports
• 

  Consumer Reports' lowest-rated cars of 2019

  
  Consumer Reports
• 

  Ancillary ways to trade the cryptocurrency craze

  
  CNBC
• 

  Russian opposition leader Navalny moved to prison hospital due to hunger strike

  
  CNBC
• 

  U.S. inflation could rise to 3-4% by the middle of 2022, strategist David Roche believes

  
  CNBC
• 

  American and Chinese economies are intertwined, says former U.S. Treasury secretary

  
  CNBC
• 

  L'Oreal's new South Asia and Middle East market to be a key 'growth engine'

  
  CNBC
• 

  Covid has taught us the importance of a sustainable future, Eir CEO

  
  CNBC
• 

  Climate expert says U.S.-China competition on energy efficiency could be a good thing

  
  CNBC
• 

  Former NYC police commissioner says verdict will 'accelerate' change in policing in the U.S.

  
  CNBC
• 

  President Biden on Chauvin verdict: Systemic racism is a stain on our nation's soul

  
  CNBC
• 

  I feel a sense of relief and a sense of resolve, says fmr. NAACP CEO

  
  CNBC
• 

  Dogecoin prices skyrocket in 2021, but slump on 'Doge Day': CNBC After Hours

  
  CNBC

Click to expand

Replay Video

• 7 muscle cars that are reasonably priced If you've always wanted a muscle car, but never thought you could afford one -- think again. GOBankingRates
• Tesla Model 3: The Complete Guide Driving a Tesla for the first time can be daunting, so we've explained everything you need to know about operating a Model 3. Car and Driver
• First driving impressions of the McLaren 600LT Spider The 600LT is now available as a Spider. We took it to the track to see how it handles. Roadshow

UP NEXT

"Elon Musk is asking people to buy a depreciating asset (a car) with an appreciating, albeit volatile, asset," Luke Sully, CEO at treasury fintech specialist Ledgermatic, said. "The underlying price volatility is the most immediate risk for merchants."

It comes down to how comfortable companies are in accepting a currency that has so much volatility in a single day, Anthony Denier, CEO of Webull, said. "You may see a few companies making the leap, but most companies are fiscally conservative and are not going to jump on a trend like this too quickly," he said.

High transaction fees

To ensure transactions go through on crypto networks, a customer is usually charged a "mining", or "network" fee. Now, regardless of the dollar amount transacted, whether carrying a value of $5 or $100, this mining fee is standard for every transaction. The fee varies depending on network demand and currently averages around $20. This element of the payment makes the bitcoin blockchain's fees unsustainable as a form of payment, according to Kaspar.

The taxman treats bitcoin as property, not currency

The Internal Revenue Service adds another layer of complication for merchants that are taxpayers in the US, because it considers bitcoin to be property, not currency, Eric Christensen, chief payment officer of e-commerce firm Digital River, said. "That means when you accept bitcoin, you register the value of it on the transaction date as the basis of that property. When you sell it, you might see a gain or a loss, all of which must be reported to the IRS."

Digital wallet regulation is a grey area

A key challenge at this point is there are only a handful of banks globally that are willing to provide stored digital facilities for the merchants they work with, according to Felix Shipkevich, founder of law-firm Shipkevich PLLC. "Regulation of digital wallets is very grey at this point," he said, adding not many jurisdictions regulate digital wallet usage between merchants and their consumers.