You are using an older browser version. Please use a supported version for the best MSN experience.

Would I burn bridges by accepting a counteroffer and turning down a new job? Ask HR

USA TODAY logo USA TODAY 5/31/2022 Johnny C. Taylor Jr.

Johnny C. Taylor Jr. tackles your human resources questions as part of a series for USA TODAY. Taylor is president and CEO of the Society for Human Resource Management, the world's largest HR professional society and author of "Reset: A Leader’s Guide to Work in an Age of Upheaval.”

The questions are submitted by readers, and Taylor's answers below have been edited for length and clarity.

Have a question? Do you have an HR or work-related question you’d like me to answer? Submit it here.

Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

Question: Upon turning in my notice at my job, my employer offered me a salary increase of 10% above my pending position and 27% above my current position. Is this a common practice? If accepted, would I burn a bridge with the prospective employer? – Lidia

Johnny C. Taylor Jr.: In today’s ultra-competitive job market, it is common for an employer to counter an employee’s new job offer with a salary increase. For employers, retention is at a premium as they seek to avoid the replacement costs of recruiting and retraining new employees. This practice can be more prevalent in specific industries where high demand for certain positions exists. If you accept the higher salary, it could burn a bridge with your prospective employer – it essentially depends on your career priorities. Your prospective employer is likely aware of the challenge of finding talent and may anticipate a counter from your current employer.

Before you decide, revisit your original reason for seeking another job. If earning more money is your priority, then engaging in the counteroffer process may be an effective way to secure a higher salary. However, if the reason you’re looking to leave is a lack of career growth, culture misalignment, or working for a difficult manager, a higher salary will not serve those interests. Allow your career priorities to inform your decision.

I’ll add this: Carefully analyzing the reasons you are seeking to leave your current employer may help determine if accepting a counteroffer is beneficial to you. It will also prevent you from accepting a counteroffer, only to leave your company in the next six months or a year. If burning bridges with the prospective employer concern you, be honest. Let them know that you did not anticipate a counteroffer and upon further reflection, you are choosing to stay. However, if the new job suits your career desires and goals, confidently move forward along your career path.

Staying put: How do I politely turn down a job offer? Ask HR

Workplace growth: Should I participate in leadership training if I'm not interested? Ask HR

UP NEXT
UP NEXT

Q: I run a New Jersey logistics facility overseeing 170 employees. Now that recreational marijuana use is legal in New Jersey, can we still screen for marijuana in drug testing? – Reilly

Taylor: The legalization of recreational marijuana does not necessarily change what employers can do in terms of drug testing. Your company has a few options to consider under the legislation.

• Employers can continue testing candidates utilizing a traditional five-panel drug test.

• Even if a candidate tests positive for THC (marijuana’s active ingredient), an employer may not refuse to hire them solely based on their drug test results.

• If an employer wants to eliminate marijuana use from the equation, it could change the drug testing policy and ask candidates to submit to a 4 four-panel test (that omits THC) rather than the traditional five-panel test.

• Or an employer could take it a step further and remove drug testing from the hiring process entirely.

So, what do you do about drug tests for current employees? Employers can still conduct random testing and testing based on reasonable suspicion of workplace usage. THC generally stays in systems for a long time, which may make it difficult to determine when an employee used marijuana or if they used it at work. If you choose to maintain a drug-free workplace, document and demonstrate a good-faith belief that an employee has violated policy. The new legislation also requires employers to conduct a physical evaluation to determine if an employee is under the influence at work.

Be sure to review your drug-free workplace policies with appropriate legal counsel to determine the best path forward for your business. Whatever you decide, I hope you have a safe, healthy and productive workplace.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Would I burn bridges by accepting a counteroffer and turning down a new job? Ask HR

AdChoices

More From USA TODAY

AdChoices
image beaconimage beaconimage beacon