You are using an older browser version. Please use a supported version for the best MSN experience.

Accident forgiveness can prevent your car insurance bill from bloating

MoneyWise logo MoneyWise 1/27/2021 Sigrid Forberg
a person standing in front of a car: How accident forgiveness keeps insurance bills low © Monkey Business Images / Shutterstock How accident forgiveness keeps insurance bills low

If you didn’t have to worry about your insurance premiums increasing after your first car accident, you could relax a little and enjoy your time in the driver’s seat more.

But how can you secure this peace of mind?

For good drivers who have managed to avoid at-fault accidents, the solution is accident forgiveness.

Read on to find out how you may be able to add this benefit to your auto insurance policy.

What is accident forgiveness?

a blue car parked on the side of a road: Robert Crum / Shutterstock © Provided by MoneyWise Robert Crum / Shutterstock

Accident forgiveness is a facet of some car insurance policies that helps drivers save money. With accident forgiveness, your insurance rate shouldn’t rise after your first at-fault accident.

Typically, you can either purchase or earn this policy feature through a good driving record. But different insurance companies will have their own approaches to this policy.

How does accident forgiveness work?

a close up of a car: Song_about_summer / Shutterstock © Provided by MoneyWise Song_about_summer / Shutterstock

Some insurance companies include accident forgiveness in their standard offerings, while others will make it available to purchase.

If you don’t already have accident forgiveness, it doesn’t hurt to ask your insurance provider about how to add it to your policy.

When you don’t have accident insurance and you receive a traffic violation, you could face what’s known as a surcharge (or penalty). Depending on your violation, this additional fee will be tacked on to your insurance premiums for about three years.

You could also face an increase to the premium itself for about the same amount of time, depending on the laws in your state.

Accident forgiveness basically gives you one do-over. If you cause an accident, it’ll go onto your driving record, but you won’t face surcharges or premium increases.

Note: If you have a few drivers listed under your insurance policy, the accident forgiveness policy generally covers everyone, but not on a per-driver basis. You’ll be covered for a single accident for all drivers included in your policy.

How can I get accident forgiveness on my car insurance policy?

a group of people sitting at a table using a laptop: Lee Charlie / Shutterstock © Provided by MoneyWise Lee Charlie / Shutterstock

Unfortunately, accident forgiveness isn’t an option for all drivers. You’ll generally have to have a spotless driving record and the policy only applies on your first at-fault accident.

So if you’ve been in a few accidents in recent years, you may not qualify for this feature. Too many speeding tickets or other moving violations on your driving record can also disqualify you from eligibility for accident forgiveness.

But if you’re a solid driver with a clean history, depending on your insurance provider, there are a few different ways you can add accident forgiveness to your policy.

Free accident forgiveness

Some companies offer accident forgiveness as a reward for remaining accident-free.

The thresholds and timelines for this perk vary by insurance company and the company will generally inform you once you’ve qualified.

But if you’re not sure if this perk is offered through your insurance provider, it doesn’t hurt to reach out and ask. They may be able to tell you how far you are from qualifying for the benefit as well.

Premium/upgraded accident forgiveness

Your insurance company may also offer accident forgiveness as a premium or upgraded feature you can pay a little extra for.

You’ll likely have to meet certain driving-record and experience standards to qualify for this feature. If you meet the threshold, you should be able to purchase the upgrade when you initially sign up for insurance or at your next renewal.

If you then have an at-fault accident and use your accident forgiveness, the additional fee should be removed from your next payment period.

What companies offer accident forgiveness?

Not all auto insurance companies offer accident forgiveness. The best way to find out whether it’s available through your provider is to check with your insurance agent.

And if your insurer won’t give you a break, maybe you can find a new one that will. It's never the wrong time to shop around for a better deal on car insurance, and with a free online tool you can instantly compare coverage and prices from various auto insurance providers in your area.

Below is a partial list of companies that offer this benefit.

  • Allstate offers accident forgiveness as an add-on to your policy. Coverage starts the day you sign up.
  • GEICO provides accident forgiveness as both a reward for drivers who maintain safe driving records and as a premium upgrade for its auto insurance policies.
  • Liberty Mutual allows drivers with a clean driving record for the last five years to purchase an accident forgiveness policy. However, this policy doesn’t apply to residents of California.
  • Nationwide only offers accident forgiveness for drivers in select states. All the drivers listed under your policy are covered, but only one accident will be “forgiven” under the policy regardless of how many drivers are listed.
  • Progressive has a loyalty rewards program that includes accident forgiveness in its benefits. The program offers forgiveness for some types of accidents so as to help resolve small claims quickly and reduce insurance premium increases.
  • The Hartford offers accident forgiveness through its Advantage Plus package and for members of the AARP (American Association of Retired Persons).
  • USAA offers free accident forgiveness for policyholders whose households have been accident-free for five years.

Alternatives to accident forgiveness

a man sitting at a desk: fizkes / Shutterstock © Provided by MoneyWise fizkes / Shutterstock

In addition to accident forgiveness, there are a few other insurance discounts that companies offer policyholders with safe records.

One common incentive is the disappearing (or vanishing) deductible. Insurance companies use a disappearing deductible to reward its accident-free drivers by either reducing or completely waiving their deductibles.

The longer you go without an accident, the lower your deductible will be.

Allstate offers its drivers a safe-driving bonus for every six months they mark without an accident. The company also has deductible rewards, which includes offering $100 off your collision deductible when you sign up, with an additional $100 off the deductible each year you drive accident-free up to a maximum discount of $500.

Some companies also use digital technology to offer usage-based insurance rates. At Progressive, it’s called Snapshot. State Farm calls its program Drive Safe & Save. But both work through an app you download onto your phone that then uses Bluetooth to track your driving.

With usage-based insurance, drivers who use their cars less frequently and have smoother rides will pay less. It also encourages fewer hard stops and distracted driving, which are common contributing factors in accidents.


More from MoneyWise

image beaconimage beaconimage beacon