You are using an older browser version. Please use a supported version for the best MSN experience.

The unluckiest generation in U.S. history

The Washington Post logo The Washington Post 5/27/2020 Andrew Van Dam

Video by WPIX

After accounting for the present crisis, the average millennial has experienced slower economic growth since entering the workforce than any other generation in U.S. history.

Millennials will bear these economic scars over the rest of their lives, in the form of lower earnings, lower wealth and delayed milestones, such as homeownership.

a close up of a map

The losses are particularly acute on the jobs front. One brutal month of the coronavirus crisis set the labor market back to the turn of the millennium. The last time there were about this many jobs (131 million) was January 2000.

a close up of a map

For millennials who came of age back then, it’s as if all the plodding expansions and jobless recoveries of their namesake epoch evaporated in a matter of weeks.

The milestones will get even more dire in the next jobs report, but for now the economic regression back to Y2K is a fitting symbol for a generation that — more than any other — has been shaped by recession.

The losses aren’t merely symbolic. This recession has steamrolled younger workers just as millennials were entering their prime working years — the oldest millennials are nearing 40, while the youngest are in their mid-20s. Millennial employment plunged by 16 percent in March and April this year, our calculations show. That’s faster than either Gen X (12 percent) or the baby boomers (13 percent).

Subscribe to the Post Most newsletter: Today’s most popular stories on The Washington Post

Proportionally, the even younger generation, known as zoomers, suffered worse than all of them. A third of their jobs were vaporized in two months in 2020. But Gen Z is only just entering the labor force — the oldest zoomers are in their early 20s — so their losses weren’t as large in absolute terms.

a close up of a logo

At the beginning of 2019, millennials had become the largest generation in the U.S. full-time workforce, surpassing Gen X. But the coronavirus crisis walloped millennials so disproportionately that they’re likely giving the top generational spot back to Gen X in the next month or two.

a close up of a map

Gray Kimbrough, an economist with American University who we’ve previously and accurately branded a serial millennial myth debunker, points out that the oldest millennials, such as himself, lived through the 9/11 terrorist attacks and entered the labor market in the recession that hit around the same time. They spent their early years struggling to find work during a so-called jobless recovery, only to be hit by the Great Recession and another jobless recovery. And, of course, yet another recession.

“The story here is not just that it’s a bad recession, and that it’s hitting young people more, but that it’s hitting people who have already been hit,” Kimbrough said.

a close up of a map

Millennials never recovered from the Great Recession

The Great Recession pushed young workers a few steps down the wage ladder. New research shows they never recovered, even as their older colleagues regained all the ground they’d lost. And now it’s happening again, to many of those same young workers.

In a 2019 working paper, Census Bureau economist Kevin Rinz used regional differences in the Great Recession’s severity to calculate that while millennial employment recovered from the Great Recession within a decade, millennial earnings never did. Building on earlier work from the University of California at Berkeley’s Danny Yagan, Rinz based his findings on more than a dozen years of annual data for more than 4.1 million people in a government database.

a close up of a map

Thanks to the Great Recession, the average millennial lost about 13 percent of their earnings between 2005 and 2017, Rinz found. That’s worse than Gen X’s 9 percent setback and almost double the 7 percent loss faced by baby boomers. By the end of the period, baby boomer earnings had recovered, even as millennials remained well below where they should have been.

Why? Suffering through high unemployment during the recession made millennials less likely to work for high-paying employers and less likely to complete as much education as workers in places where the recession didn’t hit as hard.

They had to settle for worse jobs early in their careers, depressing their lifetime earnings potential. The employer side changed, too, Rinz finds. Big employers in the hardest-hit areas consolidated their power over the local labor market and are thus able to offer less to young workers with few other options.

“If people enter the labor force during a recession and they get into lower-paying jobs? That carries forward for much of their lifelong working careers,” said Ana Kent, a policy analyst at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. “That’s going to have impacts on not only their income, but their wealth, and also their ability to save for a down payment and their ability to meet other lifetime goals.”

They weren’t ready for another one

Millennials had much less of a financial cushion than previous generations did at their age, Kent said, even though they had been doing many things right. The deck has been stacked against them. They just don’t have as many assets as previous generations did at their age.

a close up of a map

As we’ve previously shown, millennials are getting married later, having children later and, importantly, buying homes later. At a point in their lives when boomers and Gen X were already building equity, millennials have no housing net worth, Kimbrough’s recent analysis of Federal Reserve data shows.

Yet millennials are more likely to have spent within their means than Gen X or boomers were at the same age, Kent’s analysis of separate Federal Reserve data shows. That is, they’re more likely to spend less than they earn. And 52 percent of millennials were saving for retirement at age 34. At a similar age, just 42 percent of boomers had retirement savings.

“This narrative of, ‘Oh you should just work harder, sink or swim by your own effort?’ It’s very American, but it ignores the fact that the tide is much stronger now and many millennials are swimming upstream,” Kent said.

More educated, more diverse, more vulnerable

Millennials are the most educated, most diverse generation in history — at least until zoomers pass them. Those distinctions come with burdens.

“It seems overwhelmingly obvious to me that the increase in student debt that they have is more than commensurate than the increase of education,” said William Gale, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution. “Their parents and public authorities funded less of their college education than previous generations.”

That’s compounded by the large African American and Hispanic millennial population, as these groups continue to suffer the effects of generations of systemic discrimination. The wealth gap between black and white households continues to grow, even after controlling for differences in age, education, marital states and even income, Gale and several collaborators found in a working paper recently circulated by the National Bureau of Economic Research.

It’s part of trend of more marginalized groups falling behind. Millennials with a college degree aren’t far behind previous generations in terms of wealth, Kent found, but their less-educated peers have a bit more than half of the wealth they’d expect at this stage, based on previous generations.

“Not every single millennial is going to be doing more poorly,” Kent said. The 29-year-old points to herself as an example. She identifies as Hispanic, a category that’s been hit disproportionately hard by the downturn, but her PhD and white-collar job insulated her from a crisis that first hammered less-educated workers in the service industry.

But “some millennials — particularly those who are black, Hispanic or women, or who have less than a bachelor’s degree — were already financially vulnerable going into the pandemic,” Kent wrote earlier this week.

Nationally, about 12 percent of all workers couldn’t cover a $400 emergency expense — even with the help of family or credit cards — according to Kent’s analysis of Federal Reserve data. The 12 percent number holds for non-Hispanic white millennials, but the figure leaps to 32 percent for non-Hispanic black millennials, 20 percent for Hispanic millennials and 17 percent for millennial women. For all millennials with less than a bachelor’s degree, the figure is 25 percent.

a screenshot of a cell phone

“Even after so many years of economic expansion, they’re still below where we’d expect them to be,” she told us.

Not coincidentally, Kent’s analysis of Labor Department data shows women, Hispanic workers and the less-educated are also overrepresented among unemployed millennials during the pandemic.


More from The Washington Post

The Washington Post
The Washington Post
image beaconimage beaconimage beacon