You are using an older browser version. Please use a supported version for the best MSN experience.

Opening statements begin in Beaver County homicide trial

WTAE Pittsburgh logo WTAE Pittsburgh 6/10/2021
graphical user interface, application: sheldon jeter, jr. © WTAE sheldon jeter, jr.

Opening statements began Thursday in the trial of Sheldon Jeter Jr. at the Beaver County Courthouse.

Watch the report from Beaver in the video player above.

Sign up for our Newsletters

Jeter, 23, of Aliquippa, is charged with criminal homicide in the shooting death of Tyric Pugh, 30, in May 2020.

The defense claimed the two were good friends and that Jeter is not to blame for the deadly shooting in Aliquippa.

During opening statements, the prosecution said Pugh was shot six times, including 5 times in the head.

The first witnesses Thursday were two witnesses who saw Pugh's body on Kiehl Street in Aliquippa, as well as two members of Pennsylvania State Police.

State Police Trooper Clayton McGeary says they found a drivers license in Pugh's wallet that led them to an address belonging to Sheldon Jeter.

A Chevrolet SUV seen on surveillance cameras driving away from the scene shortly after the murder on May 15, 2020 was parked in the driveway.

Prosecutors say they have physical evidence they'll present.

Jeter's defense team says there's little evidence of motive in this case, though, saying that Pugh and Jeter were good friends.

"We’re telling the story, we’re telling the true story of what happened in this case, not a theory of what happened. And the true story in this case is based upon the relationship of Tyric and Sheldon, they were friends, they’d known each other their whole lives, there’s a reason the victims address is the same as Sheldon’s, clearly there’s no animosity," said Michael Santicola, who's on Jeter's defense team.

Jeter made headlines in 2018 when he was questioned, but never charged, in the death of Rachael DelTondo, who was shot in her parents' driveway in Aliquippa on Mother's Day.

DelTondo's killing remains unsolved.


Jury finds Walter Cable guilty of first-degree murder in 2017 death of Westmoreland County woman

Gun found inside backpack of student at Allegheny Traditional Academy

Pittsburgh Animal Care and Control officer charged with animal cruelty after incident with dog

Butler County couple, a former hospital COO and an ex-county detective, sentenced to prison on tax and fraud charges

Attorney who called prosecutors racist battling with judge to remain on case

Flood advisory expires for Allegheny, Westmoreland counties

READ THE FULL STORY:Opening statements begin in Beaver County homicide trial

CHECK OUT WTAE:Stay in the know with the latest Pittsburgh news, weather and sports. Catch all of the day’s top stories and more from the team at WTAE Pittsburgh Action News 4.



WTAE Pittsburgh
WTAE Pittsburgh
image beaconimage beaconimage beacon