NPR airs interview suggesting doctors perform illegal abortions as 'civil disobedience'
-
Tara Setmayer: People need to understand Republican extremists are now the mainstream. The Washington Post reported this week that the GOP is actually planning to ramp up its focus on so-called “election integrity” activities in states across the country. Meanwhile, leaked audio has exposed certain Donald Trump campaign staffers joking about spreading the Big Lie. Michael Steele in for Joy Reid and our expert guests discuss. MSNBC
-
House GOP vote to remove Ilhan Omar ‘demonized and targeted a Black Muslim woman’ Obeidallah says The fallout from the vote to remove Rep. Ilhan Omar from the Foreign Affairs Committee includes one conservative congressman who was overheard calling it, "the stupidest vote in the world." "It took 15 ballots to get him elected,” Dean Obeidallah tells The ReidOut of Kevin McCarthy vs. Rep. Omar. “It took one to demonize and target a Black Muslim woman." MSNBC
-
Chinese spy balloon ‘two to three school buses in size,’ unsafe to shoot down officials say A Chinese spy balloon is moving across the U.S. that is about the size of two to three buses, officials say. "It’s high up. It’s 60,000 feet,” NBC News correspondent Courtney Kube tells The ReidOut. “The concern is if they were to blow it up... they wouldn't be able to control the debris field. People on the ground could get hurt or even killed." MSNBC
NPR questioned whether doctors had an ethical obligation to perform abortions in states that restrict the practice, in a Tuesday morning report.
"The fear of these laws has caused some doctors to delay or deny abortions, including in emergencies," host Rachel Martin warned.
"Some doctors are asking themselves tough questions. When they are forced to choose between their ethical obligations to patients and the law, should they defy the law?" she asked.
Acts of "civil disobedience" may be necessary to provide the best care for patients, bioethicist Matthew Wynia told NPR reporter Selina Simmons-Duffin.
No health care workers have been prosecuted for defying state laws since Roe v. Wade was overturned by the Supreme Court, the report stated. But Wynia told NPR it would "certainly" happen.
Simmons-Duffin cited how the American Medical Association expressed concern that abortion laws would harm women. Her guest called for physicians to "take a stand against these laws, when necessary, using civil disobedience."
Wynia called some doctor's refusal to offer abortions in order to obey state laws, "very disturbing."
"If the law is wrong, and causing you to be involved in harming patients, you do not have to live to that law," he advocated.
PRO-LIFE CENTERS TARGETED BY 70% OF ABORTION-RELATED VIOLENT THREATS SINCE DOBBS DECISION: FBI
The reporter posed situations in which doctors may question if abortion would prioritize the health of the woman, offering the case of an Ohio woman who was initially denied an abortion after experiencing heavy bleeding from a miscarriage.
"[W]hat about when someone has a heart condition and pregnancy makes that condition worse? Or if a patient tells their doctor, 'I can't get an abortion, I'm going to harm myself,'?" she asked.
NPR went on to tout doctors who committed civil disobedience to perform abortions.
The bioethicist called on the medical community to unite and "say clearly" they will support doctors who decide to "follow the standard of care for a patient even if it violates state abortion laws."
After the Dobbs decision, Rep. Maxine Waters, D-Calif., said she would protest the court and encouraged women to defy the court's order.
In the November election, voters in the deep-blue state voted to enshrine abortion rights into state law. Opponents of the proposition called it "extreme," arguing there were no limits in the law on gestational age or viability.